A new 25-metre 5G mast beside the PSNI station on Newry Road in Armagh can now proceed after Northern Ireland’s Planning Appeals Commission overturned an earlier refusal by Armagh City, Banbridge and Craigavon Borough Council.
The appeal decision gives Cornerstone full planning approval for the telecommunications development at the BT Exchange site between the police station and Armagh City Hotel. The approval is subject to three conditions covering the mast’s appearance, the removal of equipment if it is no longer needed and the deadline for starting work.
Why the mast was proposed
The application involves removing existing rooftop telecommunications equipment and replacing it with a new lattice tower carrying six antennae and associated equipment. The proposed structure would be 25 metres high.
Around 40 metres from the proposed site, within the PSNI station grounds, there is already an existing lattice mast. However, Cornerstone said the rooftop equipment at the BT Exchange could not structurally support the new equipment required at the necessary height.
In a supporting statement submitted in 2024, the company said the BT Exchange site was important for users in the centre and south of Armagh. It said demand from commercial, educational, residential and short-term users was affecting service provision, and that the network needed to be strengthened. The new site is intended to serve O2 and Vodafone users.
The plans were initially submitted in July 2022 and were later amended. Cornerstone described itself in the original application as the UK’s leading mobile infrastructure services company.
Objections from residents and the council
Thirteen objection letters were submitted from eight postal addresses. Residents questioned whether the proposed height was necessary and argued that the benefits could be delivered by other means. They also said there were no broadband difficulties in the area.
Objectors argued that the new tower would be considerably higher than the existing mast and would be out of keeping with the surrounding landscape and visual amenities. Concerns included views towards County Armagh Golf Club and Palace Demesne, the effect on neighbouring properties and the possibility of property devaluation. The mast’s visual impact was repeatedly described in objections as an additional eyesore.
Planning officials recommended refusal. Following lengthy discussion at the council’s planning committee in July last year, the application was rejected by ABC Council.
Cornerstone then challenged the decision through the Planning Appeals Commission. Commissioner Hannah Ellison reconsidered the proposal, visited the intended location and ruled in the company’s favour.
Why permission was granted
Commissioner Ellison found that the proposed site was outside, but close to, the Armagh Conservation Area. She rejected the council’s reliance on policy concerning new development in a conservation area, finding that the policy was not applicable to the appeal.
The council had identified four viewpoints from which it believed the mast would cause visual harm. The Commissioner concluded that much of the structure would be screened from views along Scotch Street and at the junctions with Friary Road by existing trees, the police building and substantial fencing. She also considered that only the uppermost section would be visible and that the tower’s slender profile would reduce its prominence.
Her assessment was that the mast would be seen alongside an existing urban setting containing roads, traffic lanes, car parking, lighting columns and signage. She concluded that it would not cause unacceptable damage to the area’s visual amenity.
The appeal decision also addressed the effect on nearby homes on Newry Road. Although the mast would be visible from main habitable rooms and gardens, the Commissioner found that the distance between the homes and the development, together with the Golf Club car park and mature vegetation, would prevent a harmful effect on residents’ living conditions.
She also found that no evidence had been provided to show that the development would reduce property values in this particular setting.
Conditions attached to the approval
- The lattice tower must remain unpainted and in its galvanised state permanently.
- All equipment must be removed within six months if the site and equipment are no longer required.
- Work must begin within five years of the permission being granted.
The Commission’s decision means the council’s reasons for refusing the application were not upheld, and the concerns raised by third parties were not considered sufficient to prevent the development.