A Grade B1-listed home on The Mall in Armagh could become a six-bedroom guesthouse after planning officers recommended approval of proposals to refurbish the property and build a two-bedroom rear extension.

The scheme for 7 Hartford Place was due to be considered at the November meeting of the ABC Planning & Regulatory Services committee. It has attracted substantial opposition from nearby residents, with 58 objection letters submitted from 17 postal addresses against the full planning application.

A separate Listed Building Consent application received 44 letters of objection from 13 postal addresses. The planning report said all the reasons raised by objectors had been fully considered.

What is planned for 7 Hartford Place?

The proposal would change the use of the existing dwelling to a guesthouse with four bedrooms. A two-bedroom extension would be built at the rear, creating six bedrooms in total, alongside support accommodation, a lounge and dining facilities.

The plans also include associated site works, repairs to the existing garage and restoration work to the building and an outbuilding. The property fronts The Mall, with an elongated garden behind it and a greenhouse and garages at the north-east end of the garden.

According to the planning officer’s report, there would be no substantial change to the front elevation. Repair works are proposed for that elevation, while the main extension would be positioned to the rear of the dwelling.

Two applications were required because 7 Hartford Place is a listed building. Both were lodged by Weir + Weir Architects Ltd of Portadown on behalf of Mr and Mrs Coote of Woodford Drive, Armagh.

Why officers recommended approval

Planning Manager Kyle Elder told committee members that officers considered the guesthouse acceptable in principle under the Armagh Area Plan, the Strategic Planning Policy Statement and PPS 16.

“These planning applications seek full planning permission and Listed Building Consent for the change of use of an existing dwelling house to a guesthouse providing four bedrooms, with the erection of an extension to accommodate an additional two bedrooms and support accommodation.”

Mr Elder said the design would not have an unacceptable adverse effect on existing homes through overlooking, loss of light, overshadowing, noise or other disturbance. Officers also concluded that the proposal complied with policy on built heritage, including the requirements of the SPPS and PPS 6.

The report noted that the development did not include parking within the property. The applicant’s agent identified parking on local streets and in public car parks, and DfI Roads raised no objection to that arrangement.

Officers also reported no concerns about natural heritage, flood risk, drainage or sewage. Relevant consultees did not raise concerns on those issues.

The planning assessment stated that the proposal complied with the Armagh Area Plan 2004, the SPPS and other relevant planning policies. On that basis, approval was recommended. The source material describes a recommendation to the committee rather than confirming that permission had already been granted.

Supporters say it could add overnight accommodation

Uel Weir, a director at Weir + Weir Architects, said the refurbishment would respect the listed character of the property and its prominent position on The Mall.

“I’m pleased to have with me Mr and Mrs Coote, who have put a fortune of money into this project and are itching to get going ahead.”

He described the property as one of Armagh’s “heyday houses” and said the project represented an opportunity to create a high-quality guesthouse and strengthen the city’s tourism offer.

“For goodness’ sake, get this thing into Armagh. Don’t lose it. Thank you.”

Armagh councillor Scott Armstrong, who spoke positively about the conversion, said the city needed more accommodation for visitors, particularly during Georgian Day and major events across the borough.

“This here obviously seems like a positive contribution to Armagh City.”

He added that the development could help address what he described as a shortage of bed spaces in Armagh City.

Alderman Gordon Kennedy also welcomed the proposal, saying the vacant building could be brought back into use and contribute to the city’s overnight-stay accommodation.

“It’s good to see a building that had been lying vacant getting a bit of a spice-up and getting it back into circulation again.”

Planning permission and Listed Building Consent were proposed by Councillor Armstrong and seconded by Alderman Kennedy. The supplied report does not state the committee’s final decision.